Guides for parents
Column subtraction
Draft. This page hasn’t been checked yet and isn’t final. It will be reviewed before the app launches.
How it’s taught in school, why teachers say “exchange” instead of “borrow”, and how to help at home.
The short version. Write the numbers in columns, ones under ones. Start with the ones on the right. If the top digit is too small to take away from, exchange 1 from the next column: 1 ten becomes 10 ones. Cross out and write the new numbers above. Then take away, one column at a time.
When it’s taught
The national curriculum in England introduces column subtraction in Year 3. Children then use it with bigger numbers each year:
| Year | What children subtract |
|---|---|
| Year 3 | Numbers with up to 3 digits, such as 352 − 128 |
| Year 4 | Numbers with up to 4 digits, such as 4,035 − 1,672 |
| Years 5 and 6 | Numbers with more than 4 digits, such as 52,104 − 18,365 |
Before the column method, many schools show an “expanded” version first, with each number split into hundreds, tens and ones. Some schools also call the column method decomposition. If your child’s homework looks a little different from the examples here, go with how their school does it.
Why “exchange”, not “borrow”?
Many of us were taught to “borrow”. Schools now say exchange, because that’s what really happens. Nothing is borrowed, and nothing is ever given back. One ten is swapped for ten ones, like swapping a 10p coin for ten 1p coins. The number is the same, just split up differently.
For example, 52 is 5 tens and 2 ones. After an exchange, it’s 4 tens and 12 ones. That’s still 52, but now there are enough ones to take 8 away.
Using the same word as the teacher really helps. It means home and school are telling your child the same story.
A worked example: 352 − 128
This is the example Pip uses in the app. The words in Pip’s speech bubbles are what Pip says in “Show me”.
1. The ones
2 take away 8 won’t work. So we exchange 1 ten from the tens column. The 5 tens become 4 tens, and the 2 ones become 12 ones. Children cross out the 5 and write 4 above it, and cross out the 2 and write 12.
Start with the ones. Ones: 2 − 8 won’t work, so exchange 1 from the tens. That makes 12. 12 − 8 = 4. Write 4.
2. The tens
There are now 4 tens. 4 take away 2 is 2.
Tens: 4 − 2 = 2. Write 2.
3. The hundreds
3 take away 1 is 2. The answer is 224.
Hundreds: 3 − 1 = 2. Write 2.
Check it: add the answer back on. 224 + 128 = 352, so it’s right.
Zeros in the top number: 403 − 157
This is the one that catches most children out. 3 take away 7 won’t work, so we need to exchange. But there are no tens to exchange from.
So we go one more column to the left. 1 hundred is exchanged for 10 tens, then 1 of those tens is exchanged for 10 ones. That leaves 3 hundreds, 9 tens and 13 ones. It’s still 403, just split up differently.
Start with the ones. Ones: 3 − 7 won’t work, so exchange 1 from the hundreds (the 0s on the way become 9s). That makes 13. 13 − 7 = 6. Write 6.
Then the tens: 9 − 5 = 4. And the hundreds: 3 − 1 = 2. The answer is 246. Check it: 246 + 157 = 403.
Common mistakes
- Taking the smaller digit from the bigger one, whichever is on top. For 52 − 28, a child might do 8 − 2 = 6 in the ones and write 36. The right answer is 24. The bottom number is always the one being taken away.
- Exchanging, but not changing the next column. The 12 ones get written, but the 5 tens are left as 5. The answer comes out 10 too big.
- Getting stuck on zeros, as in 403 − 157 above.
- Not lining up the columns. For 1,204 − 38, the 8 must go under the 4, not under the 1. Line the numbers up from the right.
- Starting on the left. Column subtraction always starts with the ones, because an exchange changes the column to its left.
Helping at home
- Ask them to teach you. “Talk me through it” is one of the best ways to find where they’re stuck, and children love being the expert.
- Use the school’s words: ones, tens, hundreds, and exchange. If in doubt, ask the teacher how they show it in class.
- Estimate first. 352 − 128 is about 350 − 130, which is 220. If the answer is nowhere near that, something has gone wrong.
- Check by adding. Adding the answer to the bottom number should give the top number.
- Make it real. Swapping a 10p coin for ten 1p coins, or a bundle of 10 straws for 10 loose straws, shows why exchanging works.
- Little and often. A few sums most days helps more than a long session once a week.
How Pip helps
In Pip Squared, children fill in column subtraction just as they would in their maths book, starting with the ones, digit by digit.
- The sums match their year: up to 3 digits in Year 3, 4 digits in Year 4, and 5 digits in Years 5 and 6.
- Exchanges are written above the top digit, in small boxes. Writing one crosses out the digit below, as children do on paper. These jottings are never marked.
- “How it works”: the first time, Pip shows the method with the 352 − 128 example above.
- “Show me”: when they’re stuck, Pip works through their sum one column at a time, using the same words as their teacher.
- Gentle feedback: if a child types the digits in from the left, Pip spots it and says “Start with the ones, on the right.”
Subtracting is in the full version of Pip Squared, which starts with a 7-day free trial. Times tables, the daily challenge and the puzzles are always free.